Nigerian military using surveillance technology to spy on Nigerians – CPJ

Nigerian military using surveillance technology to spy on Nigerians – CPJ

The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) has accused the Nigerian military of using surveillance technology to spy on ordinary Nigerians and the press.

The CPJ stated this in a report titled ‘Nigerian military targeted journalists’ phones, computers with ‘forensic search’ for source’ published last week.

According to the report, the Nigerian military procured a forensic technology designed to extract information from phones and computers.

The report stated that two companies – Israel-based Cellebrite and US-based Access Data – that produce and market such technologies used by security forces to monitor and interrogate journalists, were already operating in Nigeria.

CPJ said between 2014 and 2017, the Nigerian government has spent at least N127 billion ($350 million) on “surveillance and security equipment.”

The report cited a 2018 report by ParadigmHQ, a Nigerian-based digital rights group, which said it has evidence “that these purchases were made for political reasons, especially by the then authorities in power to monitor their adversaries and political opponents.”

The CPJ report is coming amidst raids and attacks on journalists and newsrooms in the past few years.

PREMIUM TIMES newspaper was a victim of this raid in 2017. Plain-clothed officials of the Nigeria Police Force stormed the paper’s office in Abuja and arrested the publisher, Dapo Oloruniyomi, and judiciary correspondent, Evelyn Okakwu, because it didn’t retract a news story about the Nigerian Army and its operations. They were later released without charges.

Barely a year later, another PREMIUM TIMES reporter, Samuel Ogundipe, was arrested by officials of the State Security Service (SSS) for refusing to disclose his source of a story about the police.

In like manner, the SSS also swooped on Daily Trust newspaper offices in Maiduguri and Abuja, detaining two of its staff, Ibrahim Sawab and Uthman Abubakar. Twenty-four computers in the Abuja office were also reportedly seized.

The military said the newspaper “divulge(d) classified information, undermining national security and contravening Nigeria’s Official Secrets Act” for its report on the Nigerian military’s effort to retake six towns from Boko Haram.

The CPJ report said it took nearly seven weeks before the 24 computers confiscated during the raid were returned.

“The Daily Trust raids are emblematic of a global trend of law enforcement seizing journalists’ mobile phones and computers­­- some of their most important tools,” the report stated.

Interviews conducted in the report showed that devices are scanned through a server for scanning technology which is housed at the office of the National Security Adviser, the president’s top security aide.

Quoting a source within the Nigerian law enforcement, the report further added that security forces use “Universal Forensic Extraction Device (UFED) and Forensic Toolkit (FTK) to retrieve information from devices.”

UFED is sold by the Israel-based company Cellebrite, which is owned by the Japan-based Sun Corporation, while FTK is sold by the US-based AccessData Group, the report noted.

The report stated that Cellebrite’s website says their UFED product can “[e]xtract and decode every ounce of data within digital devices” and that their equipment is deployed “in 150 countries.”

It also has it that, in Nigeria, “authorities seized [a drug lord’s] Samsung phone” during his arrest “and extracted and analyzed data from it using UFED,” according to a case study published on Cellebrite’s website.

Like Cellebrite, the report wrote, AccessData advertises FTK as a tool to identify information on “any digital device or system producing, transmitting or storing data,” including from web history, emails, instant messages, and social media.

It also boasts the capacity to “[d]encrypt files, crack passwords, and build a report all with a single solution.”

As a means to document these attacks, Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism (PTCIJ) developed a civic technology tool called Press Attack Tracker. It documents cases of press attacks from 1985, when veteran journalist, Dele Giwa, was murdered, till date.

A total of 376 attacks on journalists in Nigeria have been documented. Of this, 373 reports have been verified and 198 violent cases reported.

When reached for comment, the army’s spokesperson, Sagir Musa, directed PREMIUM TIMES to the spokesperson of the Defence Headquarters, Onyema Nwachukwu.

Mr Nwachukwu said the Nigerian Armed Forces (AFN) cannot be working against the interest of her citizens, noting that they are committed to defending the Nigerian populace in cyberspace and not otherwise.

“The AFN cannot be working against the state and the people. Internet communication and facilities have brought about globalization and borderless policing. Whatever technologies are involved, we are not spying on Nigerians, we are defending the Nigeria state and our people in cyberspace and not otherwise as anyone may want to insinuate.” he noted.

Mr Nwachukwu said the military is engaged in several operations to tackle security challenges across the country. Bringing the public up to speed with these activities is quite acceptable but should not be conducted in a manner that could jeopardize operational security and compromise the lives of troops who are staking everything to defend the nation.

He said giving out details of impending operations certainly jeopardises operational security and puts the troops in disadvantage and the adversary in a vantage position.

“I think it will be negatively skewed to revisit isolated incidents which should not be used to consider the disposition of the military towards a critical partner and stakeholder like the media,” he said.

Statement by CWPPF on the occasion of the 2019 International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists

Statement by CWPPF on the occasion of the 2019 International Day to End Impunity for Crimes Against Journalists

The Coalition for Whistleblowers Protection and Press Freedom (CWPPF) notes the alarming trend of media censorship by state authorities in Nigeria. We observe that public officers and influential individuals are increasingly intolerant of critical reporting and fair comments by journalists. They, therefore, resort to the use of instruments of state criminal justice system to suppress freedom of expression and free press. From January 2019 till date, we have recorded 71 attacks on the media, including arrests, intimidation, detention and killings. We, as a coalition, totally condemn this abuse of power by state actors and security agencies.

Section 22 of the 1999 Constitution and several international instruments acceded to by Nigeria guarantee the right to press freedom as the media exercise their statutory duties. The right of citizens to freedom of expression, to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any medium is guaranteed under Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 19 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) also guarantees the right to seek, receive and impart information and ideas of all kinds, either orally, in writing or in print, in the form of art, or through any other media.

The flagrant disobedience of court orders and the charges of treason, terrorism and cybercrimes against citizens by Federal and State Governments set a dangerous precedent in the misuse of the state criminal justice system to silence free expression. In recent times, the Federal Government has charged journalists, including Jones Abiri and Omoyele Sowore, with treason and terrorism for engaging in social activism and practising Journalism. This is unacceptable. As if taking a cue from the federal government, the governors of Cross River, Kaduna and Kano States have followed this trend by charging Agba Jalingo, Chidi Odinkalu and Nazir Ahmad respectively with obnoxious and strange offences of terrorism, cybercrime and criminal defamation.

Furthermore, some sections of the Judiciary, as a consequence of its lack of independence, have become willing tools in the hands of state and federal governments by granting judicial approvals that stifle free speech. They do this through the demand of onerous bail conditions and unconventional trial procedures in criminal charges against journalists and other citizens. This also contributes, in no small measure, to the validation of human rights abuses by the State.

We demand that Nigeria must take steps to amend or repeal oppressive provisions of the Cybercrime (Prohibition, Prevention, etc.) Act 2015, particularly Sections 24 and 25, and other laws, which violate international and regional treaties on human rights to which Nigeria is a state party as well as Section 1(3) and 39 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended).

The government’s declared intention to regulate citizens’ use and access to social media and the civic space must not be in conflict with or constitute a breach of existing laws pertaining freedom of speech and association. Media stakeholders and the civil society need to continue to harp on the inviolability of Section 22 of the Nigerian Constitution, which accords the media the role of holding government accountable to the people. The campaign for free press must be sustained by the media and civil society to ensure that public officials fully guarantee that journalists, bloggers, broadcasters, social media users and all media practitioners are allowed to carry out their work without any form of intimidation and persecution. Government must also take concrete measures to respect, protect and ensure the effective enjoyment of the right to freedom of expression and media freedom.

Media practitioners must be proactive in the defence and protection of media freedom. We must engage in advocacy and public enlightenment while also holding regular public hearings into allegations of harassment and attacks on journalists, bloggers, broadcasters, social media users and all media practitioners’ right to freedom of expression.

We call on the African Union, regional and sub-regional bodies and the international community to prevail on state authorities in Nigeria to abide by their obligation to respect media freedom, citizen’s freedom of expression and enable the growth of a free and vibrant press in Nigeria.

Freedom of expression is critical to the sustenance of democracy and the advancement of an orderly, informed and progressive society. The Coalition is prepared to defend the interest of citizens and organisations whose rights are violated in the exercise of freedom of expression.

SIGNED

COALITION FOR WHISTLEBLOWERS PROTECTION AND PRESS FREEDOM (CWPPF)

African Centre for Media & Information Literacy (AFRICMIL)

Civic Media Lab

Civil Society Network Against Corruption (CSNAC)

Daily Trust Newspaper

International Centre for Investigative Reporting (ICIR)

International Press Centre (IPC)

HEDA Resource Centre

Media Rights Agenda (MRA)

Nigeria Union of Journalist (NUJ)

OrderPaper

Paradigm Initiative (P.I)

Premium Times (PT)

Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism (PTCIJ)

Sahara Reporters (SR)

Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP)

The Cable

Wole Soyinka Centre for Investigative Journalism (WSCIJ)

Call For Interest

Call For Interest

Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism calls for submission of interests from Lawyers with experience in Rights issues to provide legal support to Journalists as part of its Legal Aid Project.

Read More

Call for Pitches

Call for Pitches

PTCIJ’s Natural Resource Programme is pleased to invite journalists, media professionals and researchers to pitch stories that are worth investigating in the Nigeria Mining Sector.

Read More

Legal Support For Nigerian Journalists

Legal Support For Nigerian Journalists

The Media Legal Defence Initiative, in partnership with the Premium Times Centre for Investigative Journalism, has put together a project that will grant legal aid for members of the press who are victims of an attack. This is another prong in the fight for press freedom within Nigeria. Read More